Five project administration mistakes that can lead to costly construction disputes

Key takeaways

It is important to keep clear records, document tender discussions, site conditions and key project decisions to avoid uncertainty if disputes arise.

Strictly manage notices, EOT claims and other contractual requirements, as inconsistent conduct can affect parties’ rights.

Effective interface management and independent superintendent services are critical to managing delay, risk and disputes.

The complex and high-stakes nature of construction and infrastructure projects make them fertile ground for disputes. Parties typically commence a project with rose-coloured glasses and a spirit of goodwill, yet cracks frequently emerge once the initial excitement of the project wears off. The projects that fare the best when disputes arise are those where the contracting documents anticipate the likely risks for that project, and where the administration of the various agreements is properly administered.

The five deadly sins of contract administration

There are a wide range of issues that can arise in construction disputes. These include extension of time and delay cost disputes, complaints about the superintendent, ownership of float, and the application of the prevention principle, waiver and estoppel.

Together, these issues highlight five key areas where contract administration failures can create or escalate project disputes, providing practical lessons for managing contractual obligations, allocating risk and supporting successful project delivery.

1. Scope of works

Tender clarifications, site visit statements and negotiation discussions should not be left to memory alone. They should be recorded in file notes, meeting minutes, clarification schedules and, where critical, the final contract.

The scope should also be revisited whenever it changes. Variations, site instructions and informal requests from the principal’s team can quietly expand the work, so each change should be identified, priced and documented before the work is carried out wherever possible. Parties that leave scope questions until the end of the project often find that the evidence has been lost or that the other side’s recollection differs from their own.

2. Extension of time notice requirements and waiver

Extension of time (EOT) claims, delay costs, completion issues and liquidated damages are likely to become contentious without proper contract administration. Most construction contracts require a contractor to give written notice of a delay within a strict timeframe and in a particular form, and many include time bars that can extinguish a claim if the process is not followed. Poor contract administration by the head contractor or subcontractor can therefore lead to claims being time barred or otherwise rejected because they do not comply with the requirements of the contract.

The same discipline applies on the principal’s side. Inconsistent or poorly controlled contract administration by the principal’s representative or the superintendent can result in the principal being taken to have waived its right to rely on strict compliance with the contract. If a superintendent regularly assesses and grants extensions of time on claims that were lodged late or in the wrong form, it becomes difficult for the principal to insist on the notice requirements when the next claim arrives.

However, there are practical steps both sides can take, including diarising notice deadlines and tracking these in a claims register. Notices should also be given in the form and to the person the contract requires. A principal that intends to rely on strict compliance should say so promptly and consistently, for example by reserving its rights in writing, and should make sure its superintendent applies the contract in the same way on every claim.

3. Safe access and operational interfaces matter

Many projects are delivered on or alongside operating assets, such as power stations, processing plants and live infrastructure. On these sites the principal typically controls access, electrical isolations, permits to work and shutdown windows. If the principal does not organise the required isolations or access before a contractor or subcontractor attends site, work may be unable to proceed safely, and the resulting delay may be one for which the contractor can claim additional time and cost.

A subcontractor who is asked to work close to live or energised equipment before the site has been made safe is entitled to be cautious. Refusing to proceed in those circumstances is a sensible safety decision, and the resulting delay is likely to be treated as the principal’s risk rather than the contractor’s. Interface management on brownfield or live operational sites is therefore not just a technical issue. It is also a contractual, programming and safety issue, and if the principal controls the operational environment, it must administer that interface competently.

Interfacing is a risk on every project and must be managed appropriately, both through the contracts (by clearly allocating responsibility for access, isolations, permits and coordination) and through proper contract administration and scheduling. Contractors should record when access was requested, what was actually provided and the delay that followed, so that any resulting claim can be properly supported.

4. Commissioning and practical completion must be assessed against the contract actually made

Disputes about commissioning and practical completion are common, and they are often fuelled by shifting expectations late in the project. Practical completion should be assessed against the contract as actually made, including its definition of practical completion and the agreed testing, commissioning and certification framework, rather than by ad hoc dissatisfaction or changing operational concerns. A principal that introduces new requirements at the end of the project, or withholds a certificate for reasons unconnected to the contract, risks being responsible for the resulting delay.

It is also important to understand how superintendent determinations can be challenged. Where the contract permits disputes about superintendent determinations to be taken to litigation or another dispute resolution process, the decision-maker may be able to determine the underlying issues afresh and may not be confined to the material that was before the superintendent at the time. A party therefore should not assume that a superintendent’s decision will be the final word, and should continue to build its evidence after a determination is made. Contractors should also keep careful records of testing and commissioning, including when each step was completed and the reasons for any delay.

5. Superintendent independence matters

Most standard-form contracts require the superintendent to act independently and impartially when assessing claims and issuing certificates, even though the superintendent is engaged and paid by the principal. That independence is easily undermined. A superintendent who is overwhelmed and makes no determination leaves the parties without the decisions the contract relies on. A superintendent who privately signals a preliminary view to one party, or who is replaced after indicating they are inclined to make a determination the principal does not want, damages confidence in the process. Private communications between a superintendent and one contracting party undermine the role, and removing a superintendent to prevent an unwelcome determination effectively destroys it.

The superintendent’s conduct can also affect the parties’ contractual rights. If a superintendent assesses and determines an extension of time claim without insisting on compliance with the contractual notice requirements, the principal may be taken to have waived those requirements, even if that was never its intention.

A failure to ensure that a superintendent performs its functions under the contract can amount to a breach of contract by the principal. Contractors should not assume that a superintendent will personally owe them a duty of care in negligence. The principal’s contractual obligations are generally the more reliable foundation for a claim.

The principal has a duty to ensure that the superintendent acts fairly and reasonably when certifying claims under the contract. While rare, the courts have found that the failure to do so will be a breach of the contract by the principal, which opens up the principal to claims for loss and damage flowing from the breach.

In practice, principals should appoint a suitably qualified superintendent, give them the time and authority to perform the role, and avoid private communications or pressure that could compromise their independence. Contractors should direct claims to the superintendent in the manner the contract requires and, if they believe the superintendent is not acting fairly, raise their concerns in writing and promptly.

Implications

The key implication is that good projects depend on good records, disciplined notice and programme management, and genuinely independent superintendent services. Strong contract administration gives parties greater visibility over emerging risks and creates a clear record of how issues have been managed as the project progresses. It also helps ensure that contractual rights are preserved, decisions are made consistently and disagreements are addressed before they develop into larger disputes. Ultimately, investing in good contract administration throughout the life of a project is far easier than trying to reconstruct what happened once the relationship has broken down and a dispute is underway.

We're ready to assist

For further information about setting up your project for success or assistance if things go wrong on your project, please reach out to the contacts below or contact our Construction, Infrastructure and Major Projects team.